Who benefits from outsourcing? A study of one italian region’s small firms


  • Ignazio Drudi Alma Mater Studiorum - Università di Bologna
  • Silvia Pacei Alma Mater Studiorum - Università di Bologna




This paper analyses the production outsourcing of Emilia-Romagna’s small clothing manufacturers, using a new rich firm-level dataset. This dataset has the considerable advantage of containing interesting information about the outsourcing of certain phases of the production process that no other data source offers. The production process of these firms, which may be of a totally integrated or more fragmented nature, is thus analysed, and the effects of outsourcing are investigated. Since the analysis of the impact of outsourcing at the firm level has always focused more on productivity than on profitability (Olsen 2006), we are going to study the impact of outsourcing decisions both on a firm’s value added and on its gross earnings, by estimating econometric models. These models allow us to incorporate a firm’s outsourcing propensity into the impact evaluation, by adjusting for possible selection bias (Amemija 1985; Schnedler 2005). Our findings show that outsourcing has a positive effect on both productivity and, in particular, on profitability, thus confirming that Italian small clothing businesses tend to place immediate profit before productivity and growth.


T. AMEMIJA, (1985). Advanced Econometrics. Basil Blackwell, Oxford.

R. ANTONIETTI, D. ANTONIOLI, (2007). Production Offshoring and the Skill Composition of Italian Manufacturing Firms: A Counterfactual Analysis, Working Papers 2007.97, Fondazione Eni Enrico Mattei.

R.E. BALDWIN, (1999). Market Integration, Regionalism, and the Global Economy. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

G. BECATTINI, (2004). Industrial Districts. A New Approach to Industrial Change. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham.

L. BECCHETTI, S. ROSSI, (2000), The Positive Effect of Industrial District on Export Performance of Italian Firms, “The Review of Industrial Organization”, 16(1), 53-68.

L. BENGTSSON, M. DABHILKAR, (2009), Manufacturing Outsourcing and its Effect on Plant Performance- Lessons for KIBS outsourcing, “Journal of Evolutionary Economy”, 19, 231-257.

L. BENGTSSON, L. VON HARTMAN, (2005), Outsourcing Manufacturing and its Effect on Firm Performance, Paper presented at CINet, Brighton 4-6 September 2005.

S. BRUSCO, (1982), The Emilian Model: productive Decentralization and Social Integration, “Cambridge Journal of Economics”, 6, 167-184.

L. CASSIA, A. COLOMBELLI, (2009), Growth Factors in Medium-Size Enterprises: the Case of an Italian Region, “International Entrepreneurship and Management Journal”, on line from 22 October 2009.

CAPITALIA (2005), Indagine sulle imprese italiane. Rapporto sul sistema produttivo e sulla politica industriale, October 2005, in Italian.

D. CASTELLANI, A. ZANFEI, (2007). Internationalisation, Innovation and Productivity: How do Firms Differ in Italy?, “The World Economy”, Special Issue on “Export and Growth”, 30(1), 156-176.

F. DI NICOLA, (2007). Gli studi di settore: fondamenti, risultati e prospettive, Estratto Rapporto “Politiche pubbliche e redistribuzione”, ISAE, October 2007, in Italian.

J.H. DUNNING, (2000). Regions, Globalization, and the Knowledge-Based Economy. Oxford University Press, Oxford.

P. EVERAERT, G. SARENS, J. ROMMEL, (2010), Using Transaction Cost Economics to explain outsourcing of accounting, “Small Business Economics”, 35, 93-112.

M. FREO, A. GUIZZARDI, G. TASSINARI, (2011), An Insight to the Small Firms Fragmentation Under the Global Competition From a Machinery Industrial District, “International Journal of Globalization and Small Firms”, 4(3), 191-205.

C. GIANELLE, G. TATTARA, (2009). Manufacturing abroad while making profits at home: the Veneto footwear and clothing industry, in M. Morroni (ed.), “Corporate Governance, Organization and the Firm. Co-operation and Outsourcing in the Global Economy”, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham.

B. GÖRZIG, A. STEPHAN, A., (2002), Outsourcing and Firm-Level Performance, German Institute for Economic Research, Discussion Paper 309.

G. GRAZIANI (2001). International Subcontracting in the Textile and Clothing Industry, in S.W. Arndt, H. Kierzkowsky, “Fragmentation. New Production Patterns in the World Economy”, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

G.M. GROSSMAN, E. HELPMAN, (2005), Outsourcing in a Global Economy, “Review of Economic Studies”, 72(250), 135-159.

K. HARRISON, (2004), Is International Outsourcing Ethical?, “Machine Design”, 76, 16, 105.

J.J. HECKMAN, (1974), Shadow prices, market wages, and labor supply, “Econometrica”, 42, 679-693.

J.J. HECKMAN (1976), The common structure of statistical models of truncation, sample selection, and limited dependent variables and a simple estimator for such models, “Annals of Economic and Social Measurement”, 5, 475-492.

R. HELG, L. TAJOLI, (2005), Patterns of international fragmentation of production and the relative demand for labour, “North American Journal of Economics and Finance”, 16(2), 233-254.

E. HELPMAN, M.J. MELITZ, S. YEAPLE, (2004). Exports Versus FDI with Heterogeneous Firms, “American Economic Review”, 94(1), 300-316.

A. HIJZEN, (2006), International Outsourcing, Technological Change, and Wage Inequality, “Review of International Economics”, 15(I), 188-205.

D. HUMMELS, (2007), Transportation Costs and International Trade in the Second Era of Globalization, “Journal of Economic Perspectives”, 21(3), 131-154.

H.I. KULMALA, J. PARANKO, E. UUSI-RAUVA, (2002), The Role of Cost Management in Network Relationships, “International Journal of Production Economics”, 79(1), 33-43.

M.C. LACITY, L.P. WILLCOCKS, (1998), An Empirical Investigation of Information Technology Sourcing Practices: Lessons From Experience, “Manage Information System”, 22(3), 363-408.

L.F. LEE, (1993), Multivariate Tobit Models in Econometrics, in G.S. Maddala, C.R. Rao and H.D. Vinod (eds), “Handbook of Statistics 11 – Econometrics”, Chapter 6 in, Elsevier Science Publishers B.V., The Netherlands.

S. MARIOTTI, M. MULTINELLI, L. PISCITELLO, (2008), The Internationalization of Production by Italian Industrial Districts’ Firms: Structural and Behavioural Determinants, “Regional Studies”, 42(5), 719-735.

M. MAZZANTI, S. MONTRESOR, P. PINI, (2007), Outsourcing and transaction costs in “real” time and space: evidence for a province of Emilia-Romagna, “The ICFAI Journal Of Industrial Economics”, 4, 7-22.

S. MENGHINELLO, (2004), Local Engines of Global Trade: The Case of the Italian Industrial Districts, in G. Cainelli, R. Zobolo (eds.) “The Evolution of Industrial Districts. Changing Governance, Innovation, and Internationalization of Local Capitalism in Italy”, Physica Verlag, Heidelberg.

J.M. MUNOZ, D.H.B. WELSH, (2006), Outsourcing in the IT Industry: The Case of the Philippines, “International Entrepreneurship and Management Journal”, 2, 111-123.

OECD (2007), Moving Up the Value Chain: Staying Competitive in the Global Econom. Main Findings, Technical Report.

K.B. OLSEN, (2006), Productivity Impacts of Offshoring and Outsourcing: a Review, OECD Science, Technology and Industry Working Paper, 2006(1).

L. PISCITELLO, F. SGOBBI, (2004), Globalisation, E-Business and SMEs: Evidence from the Italian District of Prato, “Small Business Economics”, 22, 333-347.

W. SCHNEDLER, (2005), Likelihood Estimation for Censored Random Vectors, “Econometric Review”, 24(2), 195-217.

SMI (2009), L’industria Tessile-Moda in Italia, in “Rapporto 2008/2009. Il quadro generale”, Milano, 9 June 2009.

P. WINDRUM, A. REINSTALLER, C. BULL, (2009), The Outsourcing Productivity Paradox: Total Outsourcing, Organisational Innovation, and Long Run Productivity Growth, “Journal of Evolutionary Economy”, 19, 197-229.




How to Cite

Drudi, I., & Pacei, S. (2012). Who benefits from outsourcing? A study of one italian region’s small firms. Statistica, 72(3), 337–356. https://doi.org/10.6092/issn.1973-2201/3651