Fifteen years of labour market regulations and policies in Italy: What have we learned from their evaluation?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.6092/issn.1973-2201/3610Abstract
During the last fifteen years a notable number of labour market interventions took place in Italy, under two main headings: new regulations and implementation of active and/or passive programmes. The paper reviews a fair number of subjectively selected impact evaluation studies published in the last ten years. The framework is provided by counterfactual analysis; preliminary, its barebones are sum up. The focus of the review in on two aspects. First, a blend of empirical and analytical issues critical for credible impact evaluations are discussed. They emerge from the fact that the reviewed studies are carried out in an observational setting, and refer to prospective vs. retrospective evaluation, availability (or lack) of adequate data, over-identification tests in order to corroborate (or falsify) the identifying restriction on which the evaluation strategy rests, and heterogeneous effects. Second, the substantive evidence offered by the reviewed studies is summarized. It points to generally minor policy effects; some tentative explanations for that lack of effectiveness are suggested.References
B. ANASTASIA, M. MANCINI E U. TRIVELLATO (2009), Il sostegno al reddito dei disoccupati: note sullo stato dell’arte. Tra riformismo strisciante, inerzie dell’impianto categoriale e incerti orizzonti di flexicurity, Roma, ISAE Working Paper n. 112.
B. ANASTASIA, A. PAGGIARO E U. TRIVELLATO (2011), Gli effetti delle riforme nella regolazione e nel welfare del lavoro sulle disuguaglianze generazionali, in A. Schizzerotto, U. Trivellato e N. Sartor (Eds.), Generazioni disuguali. Le condizioni di vita dei giovani di ieri e di oggi: un confronto, Bologna, il Mulino [forthcoming].
G. BARBIERI, P. GENNARI, G. LINFANTE, E. RUSTICHELLI AND P. SESTITO (2003), Valutare i servizi pubblici per l’impiego: implicazioni delle riforme, attivismo dei servizi e chances lavorative degli utenti, “Politica Economica”, 19 (3), pp. 343-372.
G. BARBIERI, P. SESTITO (2008), Temporary workers in Italy: Who are they and where they end up, “Labour”, 22 (1), pp. 127-166.
P. BARBIERI, S. SCHERER (2007), “Vite svendute. Uno sguardo analitico sulla costruzione sociale delle prossime generazioni di esclusi”, Polis 21 (3), pp. 431-459.
F. BARCA (2009), An agenda for a reformed cohesion policy. A place-based approach to meeting European Union challenges and expectations, Brussels, Independent Report prepared at the request of Danuta Hübner, Commissioner for Regional Policy, April 2009 [http://ec.europa.eu/regional_policy/policy/future/ barca_en.htm].
A. BASSANINI, L. NUNZIATA, D. VENN (2008). Job protection legislation and productivity growth in OECD countries, Bonn, IZA Discussion Paper No. 3555.
E. BATTISTIN, M. FORT (2008), What’s missing from policy evaluation: Identification and estimation of the distribution of treatment effects, in Società Italiana di Statistica, “Atti della XLIV Riunione Scientifica”, Padova, Cleup, pp. 127-134.
E. BATTISTIN, E. RETTORE (2002), Testing for programme effects in a regression discontinuity design with imperfect compliance, “Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, A”, 165 (1), pp. 39-57.
E. BATTISTIN, E. RETTORE (2008), Ineligibles and eligible non-participants as a double comparison group in regression-discontinuity designs, “Journal of Econometrics”, 142 (2), pp. 715-730.
R. BERK (2005), Randomized experiments as the bronze standard, Paper 2005080201, Department of Statistics, UCLA [http://repositories.cdlib. org/uclastat/papers/2005080201].
C. BERLIRI, A. BULGARELLI, C. PAPPALARDO (2002), Valutazione della qualità della formazione professionale attraverso la stima dell’occupabilità, “Lavoro e Relazioni Industriali”, 1, pp. 25-44.
F. BERTON, F. DEVICIENTI, L. PACELLI (2008), Are temporary jobs a port of entry into permanent employment? Evidence from matched employer-employee data, Moncalieri, LABORatorio Riccardo Revelli - Center for Employment Studies Working Paper No. 79.
I. BISON, E. RETTORE, A. SCHIZZEROTTO (2010), “La riforma Treu e la mobilità contrattuale in Italia. Un confronto tra coorti”, in D. Checchi (ed.), Immobilità diffusa. Perché la mobilità intergenerazionale è così bassa in Italia, Bologna, il Mulino, pp. 267-296.
R. BLUNDELL, M. COSTA DIAS (2009), Alternative approaches to evaluation in empirical microeconomics, “Journal of Human Resources”, 44 (3), pp. 565-640.
M. CALIENDO (2009), Income support systems, labor market policies and labor supply. The German experience, Bonn. IZA Discussion Paper No. 4665.
D. CARD, J. KLUVE, A. WEBER (2009), Active labor market policy evaluations: A meta-analysis, Bonn, IZA Discussion Paper No. 4002.
E. CARUSO, G. PISAURO G. (2005), Licenziamenti definitivi o temporanei? Durata della disoccupazione nelle Liste di mobilità tra nuovi e vecchi datori di lavoro, “Politica Economica”, 21 (3), pp. 361-399.
COMMISSION OF THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES (2007), Towards common principles of flexicurity: More and better jobs through flexibility and security, SEC (2007)861, Brussels.
B. CONTINI, F. CORNAGLIA, C. MALPEDE, E. RETTORE (2002), Measuring the impact of the Italian CFL programme on the job opportunities for the youths, in O. Castellino and E. Fornero (Eds.), Pension policy in an integrating Europe, Cheltenham, Edward Elgar, pp. 85-105.
R. ERCOLI, A. GUELFI (2008), Schede sinottiche di studi di valutazione degli effetti di sussidi alle imprese finalizzati all’incremento dell’occupazione, in U. Trivellato (ed.), Analisi e proposte in tema di valutazione degli effetti di politiche del lavoro, Commissione di Indagine sul Lavoro, Rapporto n. 10, Roma, Cnel, pp. 131-169 [http://www.portalecnel.it/Portale/IndLavrapportiFinali.nsf/vwCapitoli? OpenView&Count=40].
S. GAGLIARDUCCI (2005), The dynamics of repeated temporary jobs, “Labour Economics”, 12 (4): 429-448.
P. GARIBALDI, L. PACELLI, A. BORGARELLO (2004), Employment protection legislation and the size of firms, “Giornale degli Economisti e Annali di Economia”, 63 (1), pp. 33-68.
F. GIORGI, A. ROSOLIA, R. TORRINI, U. TRIVELLATO (2011), Mutamenti tra generazioni nelle condizioni lavorative giovanili, in A. Schizzerotto, U. Trivellato e N. Sartor (Eds.), Generazioni disuguali. Le condizioni di vita dei giovani di ieri e di oggi: un confronto, Bologna, il Mulino [forthcoming].
J.J. HECKMAN, V.J. HOTZ (1989), Choosing among alternative non-experimental methods for estimating the impact of social programmes: the case of manpower training, “Journal of the American Statistical Association”, 84 (408), pp. 862-874.
J.J. HECKMAN, R.J. LALONDE, J.A. SMITH (1999), The economics and econometrics of active labor market programs, in O. Ashenfelter and D. Card (Eds.), Handbook of Labor Economics – Vol. 3A, Amsterdam, Elsevier, pp. 1865-2097.
A. ICHINO, F. MEALLI, T. NANNICINI (2005), Temporary Work Agencies in Italy: A springboard to permanent employment?, “Giornale degli Economisti e Annali di Economia”, 64 (1), pp. 1-27.
A. ICHINO, F. MEALLI, T. NANNICINI (2008), From temporary help jobs to permanent employment: What can we learn from matching estimators and their sensitivity?, “Journal of Applied Econometrics”, 23 (3), pp. 305-327.
G.W. IMBENS, T. LEMIEUX (2008), Regression Discontinuity Designs: A guide to practice, “Journal of Econometrics” 142 (2), pp. 615-635.
G.W. IMBENS, J.M. WOOLDRIDGE (2009), Recent developments in the econometrics of program evaluation, “Journal of Economic Literature”, 47 (1), pp. 5-86.
ISTAT (2004), La nuova rilevazione sulle forze di lavoro - Contenuti, metodologie, organizzazione, Roma.
J. KLUVE, ET AL. (2007), Active labor market policies in Europe: Performance and perspectives, Berlin-Heidelberg, Springer.
D.S: LEE (2008), Randomized experiments from non-random selection in U.S. House elections, “Journal of Econometrics”, 142 (2), pp. 675-697.
J.P. MARTIN, D. GRUBB (2001), What works and for whom: A review of OECD countries’ experience with Active Labour Market Policies, “Swedish Economic Policy Review”, 8 (1), pp. 9-56.
J.P. MARTIN, S. SCARPETTA (2011), Setting it right: Employment protection, labour reallocation and productivity, Bonn, IZA Policy Paper No. 27.
A. MARTINI (2009), RCT to test a program to place mentally ill patients into permanent jobs, Torino, Progetto Valutazione [mimeo; restricted].
A. MARTINI, L. MO COSTABELLA (2007), Una valutazione degli effetti indesiderati dell’istituto della mobilità su imprese e lavoratori, “Politica Economica”, 23 (3), pp. 259-288.
A. MARTINI, U. TRIVELLATO (2011), Sono soldi ben spesi? Perché e come valutare l’efficacia delle politiche pubbliche, Venezia, Marsilio.
J. MCCRARY (2008), Manipulation of the running variable in the Regression Discontinuity Design: A density test, “Journal of Econometrics”, 142 (2), pp. 698-714.
P. NATICCHIONI, S. LORIGA (2008), Short and long term evaluations of Public Employment Services in Italy, Discussion Paper 2008-30, Département de Sciences Économiques, Université Catholique de Louvain.
OECD (1994), The OECD jobs study: Facts, analyses, & strategies, Paris.
OECD (various years), Employment Outlook, Paris.
A. PAGGIARO, E. RETTORE, U. TRIVELLATO (2008), The effect of a longer eligibility to a labour market programme for dismissed workers, “Labour”, 23 (1), pp. 37-66.
A. PAGGIARO, E. RETTORE, U. TRIVELLATO (2010), The effect of experiencing a spell of temporary employment vs. a spell of unemployment on short-term labour market outcomes, paper presented at the 10th Econometric Society World Congress, Shanghai, August 2010 [a preliminary version appeared as IRVAPP Progress Report No. 2009-03, Trento].
S. PIRRONE, P. SESTITO (2006), Disoccupati in Italia. Tra Stato, Regioni e cacciatori di teste, Bologna, il Mulino.
S. PIRRONE, P. SESTITO (2009), Gli indirizzi della regolazione e delle politiche del lavoro: ricostruzione storica e questioni aperte, in U. Trivellato (ed.), Regolazione, welfare e politiche attive del lavoro, Commissione di Indagine sul Lavoro, Rapporto n. 11, Roma, Cnel, pp. 109-164 [http:// www.portalecnel.it/Portale/IndLavrapportiFinali.nsf/vwCapitoli?OpenView&Count=40].
P.R. ROSEMBAUM (1984), From association to causation in observational studies: The role of tests of strongly ignorable treatment assignment, “Journal of the American Statistical Association”, 79 (385), pp. 41-48.
P.R. ROSEMBAUM (1987), The role of a second control group in an observational study, “Statistical Science”, 2 (3), pp. 292-306.
F. SCHIVARDI, R. TURRINI (2008), Identifying the effects of firing restrictions through size-contingent differences in regulation, “Labour Economics”, 15 (3), pp. 482-511.
P. SESTITO (2002), Il mercato del lavoro in Italia. Com’è, come sta cambiando, Roma-Bari, Laterza.
P. SESTITO, P. GENNARI, G. BARBIERI, G. LINFANTE, E. RUSTICHELLI (2003), Valutare i servizi pubblici per l’impegno: implementazione della riforma, attivismo dei servizi e chances lavorative degli utenti, “Politica Economica”, (3), pp. 343-372.
P. SESTITO, U. TRIVELLATO (2011), Indagini dirette e fonti amministrative: dall’alternativa all’ancora incompiuta integrazione, “Rivista di Politica Economica”, July-September 2010-11 [forthcoming].
U. TRIVELLATO, S. ZEC (2008), Schede sinottiche di studi di valutazione degli effetti di politiche del lavoro, in U. Trivellato (ed.), Analisi e proposte in tema di valutazione degli effetti di politiche del lavoro, Commissione di Indagine sul Lavoro, Rapporto n. 10, Roma, Cnel, pp. 57-130. [http://www.portalecnel.it/Portale/IndLavrapportiFinali.nsf/vwCapitoli?OpenView&Count=40]
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2011 Statistica
Copyrights and publishing rights of all the texts on this journal belong to the respective authors without restrictions.
This journal is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (full legal code).
See also our Open Access Policy.
