Intra-distribution dynamics of regional per-capita income in Europe: evidence from alternative conditional


  • Roberto Basile ISAE (Institute for Studies and Economic Analyses)



In this paper different conditional density estimators are employed to analyze the cross-sectional distribution dynamics of regional per-capita income in Europe during the period 1980-2002. First, a kernel estimator with fixed bandwidth (the method traditionally applied in the literature on intra-distribution dynamics) gives evidence of convergence. With a modified estimator, proposed by Hyndman et al. (1996), with variable bandwidth and mean-bias correction, the dominant income dynamics is that of persistence and lack of cohesion: only a fraction of very poor regions improves its position over time converging towards a low relative income (“poverty trap”). Moreover, an alternative graphical technique (more informative than the traditional contour plot) is applied to visualize conditional densities.


R. BASILE (2009), Productivity polarization across regions in Europe: The Role of Nonlinearities and Spatial, “International Regional Science Review”, 31, pp. 92-115.

D. BASHTANNYK, R. HYNDMAN (2001) Bandwidth Selection for Kernel Conditional Density Estimation, “Computational Statistics and Data Analysis”, 36, pp. 279-98.

C. BRASILI, L. GUTIERREZ (2004), Regional convergence across European Union, “Development and Comp Systems 0402002, Economics Working Paper Archive”.

S. BULLI (2001), Distribution Dynamics and Cross-Country Convergence: New Evidence, “Scottish Journal of Political Economy”, 48, pp. 226-243.

W.S. CLEVELAND (1979), Robust locally-weighted regression and scatterplot smoothing, “Journal of the American Statistical Association”, 74, pp. 829-836.

W.S. CLEVELAND, S.J. DEVLIN (1988), Locally-weighted regression: an approach to regression analysis by local fitting, “Journal of the American Statistical Association”, 83, pp. 596-610.

S.N. DURLAUF, P.A. JOHNSON, J.R.W. TEMPLE (2005), Growth Econometrics, in P. Aghion, S.N. Durlauf (eds), “Handbook of Economic Growth ,Volume 1A”, North-Holland, Amsterdam.

J. FAN, Q. YAO, H. TONG (1996), Estimation of conditional densities and sensitivity measures in nonlinear dynamical systems, “Biometrika”, 83, pp. 189-206.

B. FINGLETON (1997), Specification and testing of Markov chain models: An application to convergence in the European Union, “Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics”, 59, pp. 385-403.

B. FINGLETON (1999), Estimates of Time to Convergence: An Analysis of Regions of the European Union, “International Regional Science Review”, 22, pp. 5-34.

O. GALOR (1996), Convergence? Inferences from theoretical models, “Economic Journal”, 106, 1056-1069.

P. HALL, R. WOLFF, Q. YAO (1999), Methods for estimating a conditional distribution function, “Journal of American Statistical Association”, 94, pp. 154-163.

R.J. HYNDMAN (1996), Computing and Graphing Highest Density Regions, “The American Statistician”, 50, pp. 120-126.

R.J. HYNDMAN, D.M. BASHTANNYK, G.K. GRUNWALD (1996), Estimating and visualizing conditional densities, “Journal of Computational and Graphical Statistics”, 5, 315-336.

R.J. HYNDMAN, Q. YAO (2002), Nonparametric estimation and symmetry tests for conditional density functions, “Journal of Nonparametric Statistics”, 14, pp. 259-278.

A. LAMO (2000), On Convergence Empirics: Some Evidence for Spanish Regions, “Investigaciones Economicas”, 24, pp. 681-707.

C.R. LOADER (1996), Local likelihood density estimation, “The Annals of Statistics”, 24, pp. 1602-1618.

E. LÓPEZ-BAZO, E. VAYÁ, A.J. MORA, J. SURIÑACH (1999), Regional economic dynamics and convergence in the European Union, “The Annals of Regional Science”, 33, pp. 343-370.

S. MAGRINI (1999), The Evolution of Income Disparities among the Regions of the European Union, “Regional Science and Urban Economics”, 29, pp. 257-281.

S. MAGRINI (2004), Regional (Di)Convergence, in V. HENDERSON, J.F. THISSE (eds.) “Handbook of Regional and Urban Economics”, North-Holland, Amsterdam.

M.G. PITTAU, R. ZELLI (2006), Income dynamics across EU regions: empirical evidence from kernel estimator, “Journal of Applied Econometrics”, 21, pp. 605-628.

D. QUAH (1993), Galton’s fallacy and tests of the convergence hypothesis, “Scandinavian Journal of Economics”, 95, pp.427-443.

D. QUAH (1996a), Twin Peaks: Growth and Convergence in Models of Distribution Dynamics, “Economic Journal”, 106, pp. 1045-55.

D. QUAH (1996b), Empirics for economic growth and convergence, “European Economic Review”, 40, pp.1353–1375.

D. QUAH (1996c), Convergence Emprics Across Economies with (Some) capital Mobility, “Journal of Economic Growth”, 1, pp. 95-124.

D. QUAH (1997), Empirics for growth and distribution: stratification, polarization, and convergence clubs, “Journal of Economic Growth”, 2, pp. 27-59.

D. QUAH (2007), Growth and distribution, Mimeo LSE Economc department.

M. ROSENBLATT (1969), Conditional Probability Density and Regression Estimators, in P.R. KRISHNAIAH (ed.), “Multivariate Analysis II”, Academic Press, NY.

S.J. SHEATHER, M.C. JONES (1991), A reliable data-based bandwidth selection method for kernel density estimation, “Journal of Royal Statistical Sociaty B”, 53, pp. 683-690.

A. SHORROCKS (1978), The measurement of mobility, “Econometrica”, 46, pp. 1013-1024.




How to Cite

Basile, R. (2010). Intra-distribution dynamics of regional per-capita income in Europe: evidence from alternative conditional. Statistica, 70(1), 3–22.