Recent evolution of italian households’ equity portfolio choices: an empirical investigation


  • Attilio Gardini Alma Mater Studiorum - Università di Bologna
  • Alessandro Magi Alma Mater Studiorum - Università di Bologna



We study Italian households’ portfolio choices, with a special focus on equity investments, by analysing jointly time series and cross-sectional portfolio data. We investigate the temporal evolution of the actual composition of Italian households’ investments in order to explain their portfolio choices and to detect possible determinants of the observed disequilibria phenomena. Moreover, we model the stock market participation choice by using probit regression techniques and we test for parameter stability over time. Instability of participation parameters and a peculiar evolution of Italian households’ portfolios pointed out by our concurrent analysis of cross-sectional and time series data seem to confirm the distance of Italian households’ financial decisions from the rational choice predicted by the Markowitz model. In particular, we find that the housing market bubbles interact strongly with the stock market and financial institutions seem to be unable to advise investors suggesting optimal portfolio choices. The deep reason behind these facts may be the bounded education of investors, in particular the low financial literacy of Italian households.


Y. AIT-SAHALIA, L. HANSEN, (2007), Handbook of Financial Econometrics, Elsevier Science, Amsterdam.

O. ATTANASIO, M. PAIELLA, (2007), Intertemporal consumption choices, transaction costs and limited participation in financial markets: reconciling data and theory, “Temi di discussione n. 620”, Bank of Italy.

O. ATTANASIO, A. VISSING-JORGENSEN, (2003), Stock market participation, intertemporal substitution and risk aversion, “American Economic Review, Papers & Proceedings”, 93, n. 2, pp. 383-391.

R.J. BALVERS, Y. WU, (2006), Momentum and mean reversion across national equity markets, “Journal of Empirical Finance”, 13, pp. 24-48.

D. BERGSTRESSER, J. POTERBA, (2004), Asset allocation and asset location: household evidence from the Survey of Consumer Finance, “Journal of Public Economics”, pp. 1893-1915.

R. BONCI, M. COLETTA, (2006) I conti finanziari dell’Italia dal 1950 ad oggi, in I conti finanziari: la storia, i metodi, l’Italia, i confronti internazionali, Bank of Italy, Rome, pp. 116-185.

M.W. BRANDT, (2007), Portfolio choice problems, in Y. AIT-SAHALIA, L. HANSEN (eds.), Handbook of Financial Econometrics, Elsevier Science, Amsterdam.

G. BRUNO, (2006), La trimestralizzazione delle serie storiche annuali dei conti finanziari, in I conti finanziari: la storia, i metodi, l’Italia, i confronti internazionali, Bank of Italy, Rome, pp. 187-211.

K. CHAPMAN, J.P. DOW, G. HARIHARAN, (2005), Changes in stockholding behavior: evidence from household survey data, “Finance Research Letters”, pp. 89-96.

S. CURCURU, J. HEATON, D. LUCAS, D. MOORE, (2007), Heterogeneity and portfolio choice: theory and evidence, in Handbook of Financial Econometrics, in Y. AIT-SAHALIA, L.P. HANSEN (eds.), Elsevier Science, Amsterdam.

L. D’AURIZIO, I. FAIELLA, S. IEZZI, A. NERI, (2006), L'under-reporting della ricchezza finanziaria nell’indagine sui bilanci delle famiglie, “Temi di Discussione” n. 610, Bank of Italy, Rome.

E. FAMA, K.R. FRENCH, (1992), The cross section of expected stock return, “Journal of Finance”, pp. 427-465.

K. FRENCH, J. POTERBA, (1991), International diversification and international equity markets, “American Economic Review”, 81, pp. 222-226.

A. GARDINI, A. MAGI, (2007), Stock market participation: new empirical evidence from Italian households’ behavior, “Giornale degli Economisti e Annali di Economia”, 66, n. 1, pp. 93-114.

F. GOMES, A. MICHAELIDES, (2005), Optimal life-cycle asset allocation: understanding the empirical evidence, “Journal of Finance”, 60, pp. 869-904.

L.P. HANSEN, R. JAGANNATHAN, (1991), Implications of security market data for models of dynamic economies, “Journal of Political Economy”, pp. 443-487.

J. HEATON, D.J. LUCAS, (1996), Evaluating the effects of incomplete markets on risk sharing and asset pricing, “Journal of Political Economy”, pp. 443-487.

J. HEATON, (1995), An empirical investigation of asset pricing with temporally dependent preference specification, “Econometrica”, pp. 681-717.

S. HOCHGUERTEL, (2001), The relation between financial and housing wealth: evidence from Dutch households, “Journal of Urban Economics”, pp. 374-403.

A. MAGI, (2007), Razionalità limitata, scelte di portafoglio e investimento azionario estero, “Moneta e Credito”, 60, n. 238, pp. 141-171.

G. MANKIW, S. ZELDES, (1991), The consumption of stockholders and non-stockholders, “Journal of Financial Economics”, 29, pp. 97-112.

H. MARKOWITZ, (1952), Portfolio selection, “Journal of Finance”, pp. 77-91.

R. MEHRA, E. PRESCOTT, (1985), The equity premium: a puzzle, “Journal of Monetary Economics”, 15, pp. 145-161.

S. MENGOLI, (2004), On the source of contrarian and momentum strategies in Italian equity market, “International Review of Financial Analysis”, pp. 301-331.

M. PAIELLA, (2007), The forgone gains of incomplete portfolios, “Review of Financial Studies”, 20, n. 5, pp. 1623-1646.

J. PIJOAN-MAS, (2007), Pricing risk in economies with heterogeneous agents and incomplete markets, “Journal of the European Economic Association”, pp. 987-1015.

R. SHILLER, (2000), Irrational Exuberance, Princeton University Press. R. SHILLER, (2003), From efficient market theory to behavioral finance, “Journal of Economic Perspectives”, pp. 83-104.

P. SHUM, M. FAIG, (2006), What explain household stockholdings? “Journal of Banking and Finance”, pp. 2579-2597.

M. VAN ROOIJ, A. LUSARDI, R. ALESSIE, (2007), Financial literacy and stock market participation, “CERP working paper”, n. 66.

A. VISSING-JORGENSEN, (2002), Towards an explanation of household portfolio choice heterogeneity: nonfinancial income and participation cost structures, “NBER working paper”, n. 8884.




How to Cite

Gardini, A., & Magi, A. (2007). Recent evolution of italian households’ equity portfolio choices: an empirical investigation. Statistica, 67(2), 119–141.